home *** CD-ROM | disk | FTP | other *** search
- <text id=94TT0259>
- <title>
- Feb. 28, 1994: The Arts & Media:Television
- </title>
- <history>
- TIME--The Weekly Newsmagazine--1994
- Feb. 28, 1994 Ministry of Rage:Louis Farrakhan
- </history>
- <article>
- <source>Time Magazine</source>
- <hdr>
- THE ARTS & MEDIA, Page 60
- Television
- Murder, They Wheezed
- </hdr>
- <body>
- <p>Starring in sitcoms may get too strenuous, but in prime time
- you're never too old to solve a whodunit
- </p>
- <p>By Richard Zoglin--With reporting by Jeffrey Ressner/Los Angeles
- </p>
- <p> Alexander Scott, the globe-trotting secret agent played by
- Bill Cosby in the 1960s series I Spy, made a return visit to
- his old top-secret agency a couple of weeks ago. And no one
- was more surprised than the security guard who had to inspect
- his outdated photo ID. "Long assignment?" she asked skeptically.
- "Sick leave," he replied.
- </p>
- <p> It may be too harsh to call them the over-the-hill gang. But
- TV's newest batch of prime-time detectives are, let us say,
- not the sleuths you'd feel most comfortable hiring to follow
- an armed robber down a dark alley. Cosby, now 56 and with a
- No. 1-rated sitcom under his (expanding) belt, not only resurfaced
- in I Spy Returns on CBS but also played a police crime consultant
- in The Cosby Mysteries, the first of a planned series of NBC
- movies. Dick Van Dyke, now an avuncular 68, portrays a crime-solving
- physician in the CBS series Diagnosis Murder, and Gene Barry,
- 74, is back in Burke's Law, a new version of the '60s series
- about a millionaire police detective who tools to crime scenes
- in a chauffeur-driven Rolls-Royce.
- </p>
- <p> In yet another TV revival, Robert Wagner, 64, and Stefanie Powers,
- 51, returned last week in Hart to Hart: Home Is Where the Hart
- Is, an NBC movie based on their decade-old series about high-living
- husband-and-wife detectives. George C. Scott and Louis Gossett
- Jr. are among the stars who will join the old-codger crime-fighting
- brigade later this spring. Add to these such veteran TV sleuths
- as Angela Lansbury in Murder, She Wrote, Andy Griffith in Matlock
- and Peter Falk in occasional Columbo movies, and you've got
- enough votes to block Clinton's Medicare reforms.
- </p>
- <p> Detective shows are the low-impact aerobics of network programming.
- To an aging star for whom feature-film roles have dried up and
- sitcoms are too demanding, a detective show can be a comfortable
- sinecure. For viewers tired of raucous sitcoms and hard-charging
- magazine shows, these TV whodunits provide easy-to-take, low-decibel
- entertainment. Murder, She Wrote, in its 10th season on CBS,
- is still a Top 10 hit; ABC's Matlock is a solid success in one
- of the week's toughest time periods; Diagnosis Murder and Burke's
- Law, new this season, have given CBS its best Friday-night ratings
- in years.
- </p>
- <p> Even so, the genre has had to struggle to get back into network
- favor. The audience for these shows tends to be older, at a
- time when advertisers seem obsessed with targeting the young
- crowd. A recent Nielsen survey found that Murder, She Wrote,
- despite its high ratings, gets less for a 30-second commercial
- than its low-rated (but younger-skewing) Sunday-night competitor
- SeaQuest DSV.
- </p>
- <p> Yet by the same token, the shows offer counterprogramming to
- youth-oriented sitcoms, plus a way to lure back the broad-based
- family audience that has drifted away from network TV. "Every
- segment of the audience has value," says CBS Entertainment executive
- vice president Peter Tortorici. "The better job you do of connecting
- them so you can get them to watch together is, ultimately, the
- best use you can make of the medium."
- </p>
- <p> Viewers from eight to 80 have little trouble recognizing the
- unwavering formulas of these arthritic whodunits: murder discovered,
- suspects questioned, red herrings introduced, culprit finally
- tripped up and exposed. Not every show is as hokey and mechanical
- as Burke's Law, which routinely ends with a scene in which Burke
- gathers all the suspects and eliminates them one by one until
- he fingers the guilty party. The better shows at least try to
- bring their criminology into the '90s: the key to the solution
- of Cosby's first mystery--Who is murdering a corporation's
- top executives?--was the redial feature on a victim's car
- fax.
- </p>
- <p> Compared with the hard-nosed crime fighters in more realistic
- police shows like NYPD Blue and Law & Order, these detectives
- are easygoing dilettantes. For many, the job is just a sideline,
- sometimes a reluctant one. "I don't want to work," whines Cosby's
- character, who is trying to retire after winning the lottery.
- "I just want to stay here and sleep and play my clarinet." Van
- Dyke works in a metropolitan hospital, yet he seems to have
- unlimited time to run down clues in an effort to clear people
- falsely accused of murder--people who, far too often, are
- old personal friends. (With friends like these...)
- </p>
- <p> Happily, these graying gumshoes are, for the most part, spared
- the indignity of fistfights, car chases and other demanding
- physical stunts. Typically, they have a younger partner who
- does most of the heavy lifting. (Both Barry and Van Dyke, for
- instance, are teamed with sons on the police force; Van Dyke's
- is played by his real-life son Barry Van Dyke.) Yet even the
- few spurts of physical action can be discomfiting: last week's
- Hart to Hart revival brought back Lionel Stander, now 86, as
- the Harts' Man Friday, then forced the poor fellow to pursue
- a suspect (played by Alan Young, 74) over a rocky New England
- beach. Ben-Gay, anyone?
- </p>
- <p> Though classic TV escapism, these shows may be filling a societal
- need. "They put an `entertainment grid' on the explosion of
- crime that's really happening out there," suggests William S.
- Link, co-creator of Columbo and Murder, She Wrote as well as
- The Cosby Mysteries. "Today's crime rate is the highest in history.
- People want to see some sort of control, and you get that with
- fiction. On TV, the heavies are always caught."
- </p>
- <p> The heavies, moreover, are considerably less frightening than
- those in real life. Murders on these shows are nearly always
- committed by well-groomed, well-to-do white people, and the
- deeds are neat, bloodless, imaginatively staged. In recent weeks
- we have seen a magician drown in a tank of water when his escape
- trick is sabotaged (Diagnosis Murder); a late-night TV host
- electrocuted by his microphone at a Friars-type roast (Burke's
- Law); and a manic-depressive book editor driven to near madness
- and pushed off a building roof to feign a suicide (Murder, She
- Wrote). Murders are never random or accidental or committed
- in the heat of passion; they are carefully planned by people
- with clear, easily understood motives.
- </p>
- <p> "One of you here tonight is a murderer, and I'm going to prove
- it," Van Dyke announces just before exposing the magician's
- killer. What's nice about TV mysteries, as opposed to real-life
- ones, is that the culprit is always "here tonight." Which may
- be one reason why the Nancy Kerrigan-Tonya Harding story has
- struck such a chord. Kerrigan's attacker was not, as most people
- assumed at first, a crazed fan or a random nut. The crime appears
- to have been--just like TV!--an elaborately plotted effort
- by another skater's camp to eliminate a rival. Any fan of Murder,
- She Wrote can recognize the motive. And not even Columbo could
- have cracked the case faster.
- </p>
-
- </body>
- </article>
- </text>
-
-